A judge will decide on the final settlement of a claim for brain damage due to surgical negligence after approving a third interim compensation payment.
In November 2001, Eoin O´Mahony was just nineteen years of age and a Leaving Certificate student when he was referred to the Cork University Hospital complaining of headaches. Eoin underwent brain surgery on 23rd November to reduce the pressure on his brain and a second procedure on 30th November to remove part of a tumour that had been discovered.
Due to surgical errors during the operations, Eoin lapsed into a coma on 1st December. When he came round from the coma, Eoin was diagnosed with locked-in syndrome – a condition in which a patient is fully aware of his or her surroundings, but is unable to move or communicate verbally due to complete paralysis of nearly all the voluntary muscles in the body.
The Cork University Hospital acknowledge liability for Eoin´s brain damage in 2009, and two interim compensation payments amounting to €4.1 million have been paid to his parents while the courts have been waiting for a structured periodic payment system being introduced. On this occasion, Eoin´s parents requested a lump sum final settlement of the claim for brain damage due to surgical negligence as they have already endured thirteen years of litigation on their son´s behalf.
At the High Court, Mr Justice Michael Moriarty agreed to their request; but after nineteen days of hearings – during which reports concerning Eoin´s future requirements were discussed – no agreement could be reached on a final settlement. Mr Justice Michael Moriarty instructed the parties that a final settlement should be between €10 million and €10.1 and briefly adjourned the hearing to allow for negotiations to continue out of court.
When the hearing resumed, Eoin´s legal team advised Judge Moriarty that the family had been prepared to split the difference in the figures that the judge had quoted as the family wanted to resolve the claim for brain damage due to surgical negligence once and for all – but the State Claims Agency would not agree to this arrangement.
The judge said that he would make a decision on the final settlement of the claim for brain damage due to surgical negligence, and promised the family that they would know his decision no later than October. Judge Moriarty then instructed the State Claims Agency to make a third interim compensation payment of €800,000 to cover the medical and care costs that Eoin´s family would incur in the intervening period.